|
All in all a great book that I will definitely recommend to my friends. Some of the scenes, especially the initial battle with the Incas, and the later sieges, were really thrilling.
The author did an excellent job of providing just enough background to understand the motivations of the various (and numerous) historical characters without slowing the narrative flow. "Last Days" is a wonderful read, and a really engrossing book.
I could see his loyalties were with the Incas (hard not to feel that way) but he was still able to provide a balanced account. I also appreciated how he didn't sugarcoat the Incas themselves, but showed their own proclivity for violence and torture.
The Incas could be pretty nasty when they wanted to be. Not an easy accomplishment, especially when you know the outcome.
This should get made into a movie (the characters are much more interesting than "Avatar").
MacQuarrie is faster and more fiction-like read. The Incas are able to consolidate their many tribes, but the rebellions all flame out.
Whereas John Hemming's Conquest of the Incas is the definitive modern history, MacQuarrie brings to bear a more narrative and engaging approach.Last Days is historically thorough, but MacQuarrie writes many of the incidents of the conquest in a more fictional style. The Last Days of the Incas is a terrifically readable history of the Spanish conquest of the Incas and Peru.
This small band (aided unknowingly by a smallpox plague ravaging North, Central and South America) kidnap and kill their way to riches and domination. Often scenes are are qualified with comments like "Undoubtedly, Pizarro felt such-and-such," or "No doubt Manco looked out over the valley, etc." Once one accepts the speculative commentary for what it is, it shouldn't be bothersome, and is more than made up for by the narrative flow.The story of the conquest is well-known: Pizarro & co.
swoop into Peru with only a handful of fully armed conquistadors looking for fame and fortune. Ultimately, the Spanish prevail despite their own internecine battles that ends in the death of Francisco Pizarro by Spanish hands.John Hemming is for the hardest core academic reading of the Incan conquest.
Both are highly recommended.
This book has all the elements of a riveting piece of fiction.BUT, it's a nonfiction. The writing is superb. It will keep you hooked and teach you some history in the process.
This book is a great gift, extremely informative with much more depth than I expected, and it's really, really well written, too. It clearly shows an amazing picture of cultural clash between Indians and Spaniards, one which other reviewers have outlined. Well done, Kim, thank you. I'm buying a copy for my daughter.
The book is one of the most fascinating I've read, ever. When I bought it I half expected a rather dull read. When I stumbled upon this book I was looking for some history that was out of the ordinary for my reading. While I knew roughly how the story ends, I found myself hoping the embattled Incas were going to pull it out at the last minute. What a surprise. I really had no idea. The very idea that this small group of Spaniards would ever undertake such an action seems beyond belief and the story of the Inca's resistance is amazing.The author's writing style is imminently readable and I found myself to be astonished by the amount of research that must have been required. I cannot recommend it highly enough.
|